Huatao Group-Vibrating Screen Technology Solution and Service for Quarry & Mining Industry Since 2008.
|
Feature |
Self-Cleaning Overband Magnet |
Magnetic Head Pulley |
|
Mounting position |
Suspended above the belt, at the head end or mid-span |
Replaces or sits inside the head pulley at the discharge |
|
Capture mechanism |
Lifts ferrous pieces up out of the burden |
Holds ferrous pieces against the belt past the normal trajectory |
|
Effective burden depth |
150–300 mm depending on field and gap |
Roughly 50–100 mm in practice |
|
Iron discharge |
Cleated belt carries iron sideways into a chute |
Iron drops behind a splitter into a reject chute |
|
Headroom required |
500–700 mm above the belt plus chute |
None above the belt |
|
Power demand |
0.75–2.2 kW drive (permanent); 5–12 kW/m width (electromagnetic) |
Zero — passive permanent magnet |
|
Indicative capital cost, 1,000 mm |
US$18,000–35,000 plus frame |
US$6,000–14,000 |
|
Best fit |
Deep burden, high tonnage, heavy iron load |
Thin even burden, tight headroom, pulley replacement due |
|
Main weak point |
Structure, headroom, discharge chute plugging |
Shallow reach, splitter sensitivity, lagging wear |
Aggregate is not one application. The same plant may need different answers at different conveyors:
|
Application |
Typical iron |
Recommended device |
|
Quarry primary feed after the hopper |
Drill steel, bucket teeth, GET pins |
Self-cleaning overband, deep field |
|
Secondary cone feed |
Screen wire, liner bolts, small hardware |
Overband, or pulley where burden is thin |
|
Recycled concrete and C&D |
Rebar, mesh, wire bundles |
Overband plus metal detector |
|
Asphalt millings (RAP) |
Wire, blade tips |
Pulley on thin, dry belts |
|
Sand and gravel washing feed |
Small hardware, wire |
Pulley, or rare-earth overband for fines |
|
Slag and foundry by-product |
Partly magnetic lumps |
Electromagnetic overband |
|
Cement and limestone |
Chain, bolts, scale |
Overband with heavy-duty cleats |
|
Mobile and tracked plants |
Mixed, unpredictable |
Compact permanent overband |
The magnet material matters as much as the mounting method, and it is where most of the price spread lives.
|
Magnet option |
Field at belt |
Cost index |
Temperature limit |
Best use |
|
Ceramic (ferrite) pulley |
Moderate, shallow |
1.0 |
250–300 °C |
Coarse surface iron on thin beds |
|
Rare earth (NdFeB) pulley |
Strong, still shallow |
1.6–2.2 |
80 °C standard, 200 °C special grades |
Small iron on thin beds |
|
Permanent overband, ceramic |
Moderate depth |
1.8 |
250–300 °C |
Coarse iron, moderate burden |
|
Permanent overband, rare earth |
Deep, strong on fines |
2.6–3.5 |
80 °C standard |
Fine iron, high-value protection |
|
Electromagnetic overband |
Deepest, adjustable |
3.5–5.0 |
Coil-limited, needs cooling |
Deep beds, heavy pieces, high tonnage |
For aggregate duty, a permanent rare-earth overband is the usual sweet spot: no rectifier to fail, no coil cooling, and enough gradient to hold a 20 g bolt at a 250 mm gap. Electromagnetic units earn their power bill on iron ore, deep beds and pieces above roughly 15 kg. On the pulley side, ceramic is normally sufficient because the pulley's reach is limited by burden depth long before it is limited by field strength — paying for rare earth in a pulley often buys gauss the geometry cannot use.
|
Cost element |
Self-cleaning overband (1,000 mm, permanent RE) |
Magnetic head pulley (1,000 mm face) |
|
Equipment |
US$18,000–35,000 |
US$6,000–14,000 |
|
Support structure and chute |
US$5,000–15,000 |
Nil |
|
Electrical |
US$1,500–4,000 |
Nil |
|
Installation labour |
2–4 days, crane required |
1–2 days, conveyor downtime |
|
Annual spares |
US$1,000–2,500 (cleats, belt, bearings) |
US$300–900 (lagging, bearings) |
|
Annual power |
3,000–15,000 kWh |
Nil |
|
Capture of surface iron |
High |
High |
|
Capture of buried iron |
Moderate to high |
Low |
|
Five-year TCO, indicative |
US$32,000–58,000 |
US$9,000–19,000 |
|
Failure mode that hurts |
Chute plugging, cleat wear, belt tracking |
Splitter mis-set, lagging wear, field shorted by steel cords |
The TCO table explains why "which is cheaper" is the wrong question. The pulley is cheaper on every line, and it is the right answer whenever the iron it can see is the iron that is causing the damage. It is the wrong answer on a 200 mm bed where the dangerous pieces are buried.
The overband-versus-pulley question is not a brand question or a budget question; it is a measurement question. A magnetic pulley is an elegant, passive, inexpensive device that removes surface iron beautifully — and it cannot see through 180 mm of granite. A self-cleaning overband reaches into the burden, discharges continuously and costs two to three times as much, and on a deep-bed primary feed it is the only one of the two that does the job.
So measure the burden, count the iron, check the headroom and the head pulley, then choose. Where the burden is thin and the belt is fabric, buy the pulley and spend the savings on a metal detector. Where the burden is deep, the belt is steel-cord or the crusher behind it is expensive to stop, buy the overband and design the chute properly. And on any plant with more than one iron pathway, use both — the cheapest protection is usually the device that matches the geometry of the conveyor it sits on, not the device with the biggest magnet.
Technician inspecting conveyor head-end components at an aggregate plant during a maintenance shift
Related Products
Related Technical Guides
Related Buyer Guides
Related Comparison Guides
Contact: Annie Lu
Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com
Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676
Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com
We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.