loading

Huatao Group-Vibrating Screen Technology Solution and Service for Quarry & Mining Industry Since 2008.

Overband Magnet or Magnetic Pulley at the Head End: Which One Actually Protects an Aggregate Crusher?

Key Takeaways

  • ✔ An overband magnet works from the top of the burden downwards; a magnetic pulley only works on iron that is close to the belt surface.
  • ✔ A magnetic pulley typically costs 40–60% less than a comparable self-cleaning overband, but its effective capture depth is limited to roughly 50–100 mm of aggregate.
  • ✔ Overband installation usually fails on structure and headroom, not on magnetics — 500–700 mm of clear space plus a discharge chute is mandatory.
  • ✔ Splitter plate position decides product loss on a pulley installation as much as field strength decides capture.
  • ✔ Steel-cord belts short-circuit the pulley field and are a poor match for magnetic pulleys.
  • ✔ Neither technology sees manganese steel, stainless or aluminium; a metal detector with a belt-stop interlock covers that gap.
  • ✔ At 180 mm burden on a 1,000 mm belt, the overband is almost always the correct specification regardless of price.
  • ✔ The cheapest total cost of ownership often comes from a pulley at a clean, thin-burden transfer point plus an overband on the dirty primary feed.

Summary Table

Feature

Self-Cleaning Overband Magnet

Magnetic Head Pulley

Mounting position

Suspended above the belt, at the head end or mid-span

Replaces or sits inside the head pulley at the discharge

Capture mechanism

Lifts ferrous pieces up out of the burden

Holds ferrous pieces against the belt past the normal trajectory

Effective burden depth

150–300 mm depending on field and gap

Roughly 50–100 mm in practice

Iron discharge

Cleated belt carries iron sideways into a chute

Iron drops behind a splitter into a reject chute

Headroom required

500–700 mm above the belt plus chute

None above the belt

Power demand

0.75–2.2 kW drive (permanent); 5–12 kW/m width (electromagnetic)

Zero — passive permanent magnet

Indicative capital cost, 1,000 mm

US$18,000–35,000 plus frame

US$6,000–14,000

Best fit

Deep burden, high tonnage, heavy iron load

Thin even burden, tight headroom, pulley replacement due

Main weak point

Structure, headroom, discharge chute plugging

Shallow reach, splitter sensitivity, lagging wear

Overband Magnet or Magnetic Pulley at the Head End: Which One Actually Protects an Aggregate Crusher? 1Overband Magnet or Magnetic Pulley at the Head End: Which One Actually Protects an Aggregate Crusher? 2

Applications and Industry Fit

Aggregate is not one application. The same plant may need different answers at different conveyors:

Application

Typical iron

Recommended device

Quarry primary feed after the hopper

Drill steel, bucket teeth, GET pins

Self-cleaning overband, deep field

Secondary cone feed

Screen wire, liner bolts, small hardware

Overband, or pulley where burden is thin

Recycled concrete and C&D

Rebar, mesh, wire bundles

Overband plus metal detector

Asphalt millings (RAP)

Wire, blade tips

Pulley on thin, dry belts

Sand and gravel washing feed

Small hardware, wire

Pulley, or rare-earth overband for fines

Slag and foundry by-product

Partly magnetic lumps

Electromagnetic overband

Cement and limestone

Chain, bolts, scale

Overband with heavy-duty cleats

Mobile and tracked plants

Mixed, unpredictable

Compact permanent overband

Material Comparison

The magnet material matters as much as the mounting method, and it is where most of the price spread lives.

Magnet option

Field at belt

Cost index

Temperature limit

Best use

Ceramic (ferrite) pulley

Moderate, shallow

1.0

250–300 °C

Coarse surface iron on thin beds

Rare earth (NdFeB) pulley

Strong, still shallow

1.6–2.2

80 °C standard, 200 °C special grades

Small iron on thin beds

Permanent overband, ceramic

Moderate depth

1.8

250–300 °C

Coarse iron, moderate burden

Permanent overband, rare earth

Deep, strong on fines

2.6–3.5

80 °C standard

Fine iron, high-value protection

Electromagnetic overband

Deepest, adjustable

3.5–5.0

Coil-limited, needs cooling

Deep beds, heavy pieces, high tonnage

For aggregate duty, a permanent rare-earth overband is the usual sweet spot: no rectifier to fail, no coil cooling, and enough gradient to hold a 20 g bolt at a 250 mm gap. Electromagnetic units earn their power bill on iron ore, deep beds and pieces above roughly 15 kg. On the pulley side, ceramic is normally sufficient because the pulley's reach is limited by burden depth long before it is limited by field strength — paying for rare earth in a pulley often buys gauss the geometry cannot use.

Application Comparison: Capital, Running Cost and Total Cost of Ownership

Cost element

Self-cleaning overband (1,000 mm, permanent RE)

Magnetic head pulley (1,000 mm face)

Equipment

US$18,000–35,000

US$6,000–14,000

Support structure and chute

US$5,000–15,000

Nil

Electrical

US$1,500–4,000

Nil

Installation labour

2–4 days, crane required

1–2 days, conveyor downtime

Annual spares

US$1,000–2,500 (cleats, belt, bearings)

US$300–900 (lagging, bearings)

Annual power

3,000–15,000 kWh

Nil

Capture of surface iron

High

High

Capture of buried iron

Moderate to high

Low

Five-year TCO, indicative

US$32,000–58,000

US$9,000–19,000

Failure mode that hurts

Chute plugging, cleat wear, belt tracking

Splitter mis-set, lagging wear, field shorted by steel cords

The TCO table explains why "which is cheaper" is the wrong question. The pulley is cheaper on every line, and it is the right answer whenever the iron it can see is the iron that is causing the damage. It is the wrong answer on a 200 mm bed where the dangerous pieces are buried.

Overband Magnet or Magnetic Pulley at the Head End: Which One Actually Protects an Aggregate Crusher? 3

Conclusion

The overband-versus-pulley question is not a brand question or a budget question; it is a measurement question. A magnetic pulley is an elegant, passive, inexpensive device that removes surface iron beautifully — and it cannot see through 180 mm of granite. A self-cleaning overband reaches into the burden, discharges continuously and costs two to three times as much, and on a deep-bed primary feed it is the only one of the two that does the job.

So measure the burden, count the iron, check the headroom and the head pulley, then choose. Where the burden is thin and the belt is fabric, buy the pulley and spend the savings on a metal detector. Where the burden is deep, the belt is steel-cord or the crusher behind it is expensive to stop, buy the overband and design the chute properly. And on any plant with more than one iron pathway, use both — the cheapest protection is usually the device that matches the geometry of the conveyor it sits on, not the device with the biggest magnet.

 

Technician inspecting conveyor head-end components at an aggregate plant during a maintenance shift

Related Articles

Related Products

  • Self-Cleaning Electromagnetic Separator
  • Electromagnetic Overband Separator
  • Magnetic Drum
  • Magnetic Roller
  • Iron Magnet
  • Magnetic Drums & Rollers

Related Technical Guides

  • Improve Fine Screening Efficiency with Polyurethane Screen Panels
  • Hydrocyclone Wear: Root Causes, High-Wear Zones & Material Solutions
  • Hydrocyclone Underflow Too Wet? 6 Causes & Fixes
  • Flotation Cell Rotor and Stator Wear Parts: How They Control Recovery, Flow and Maintenance Cost
  • Rotor & Stator in Mechanical Flotation Cells: The Heart of Efficient Mineral Flotation

Related Buyer Guides

  • Which Manufacturer Offers High-Quality Polyurethane Tufflex Wire Screens for Mining?
  • How Do I Choose the Right Rubber Belt for a Vacuum Belt Filter?

Related Comparison Guides

  • Polyurethane Screen vs Rubber Screen vs Wire Mesh: A Complete Comparison Guide
  • Self-Cleaning Screen vs Traditional Woven Wire Mesh: Which One Should You Choose?

Contact Us

Contact: Annie Lu

Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com

Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676

Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com

We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.

prev
PU Mesh Panel Specifications to Check Before Ordering
recommended for you
Get in touch with us
Customer service