loading

Huatao Group-Vibrating Screen Technology Solution and Service for Quarry & Mining Industry Since 2008.

Self-Cleaning Magnet Keeps Picking Up Manganese Steel —

Is That Expected or Is My Field Too Strong?

Quick Answer

Genuine, correctly solution-annealed Hadfield manganese steel is essentially paramagnetic and should not cling firmly to a self-cleaning magnetic separator. If your magnet keeps lifting manganese steel liners, the usual causes are mislabeled carbon steel, magnetic weld zones, work-hardened surfaces that have developed strain-induced martensite, or a field that reaches too deep for the duty. In practice, material identity explains roughly 70% of these cases; field tuning explains most of the rest. Verify the steel first, then adjust suspension height or field depth — never simply accept the pickup as normal.

Key Takeaways

  • Annealed Hadfield manganese steel (11–14% Mn) is austenitic and only weakly paramagnetic — a magnet should not hold it by its own weight.
  • Work hardening, welding, or missing solution annealing can turn any "manganese steel" part weakly or strongly ferromagnetic.
  • Most "magnetic manganese steel" is actually mislabeled carbon steel, mixed lots, or un-annealed castings.
  • Field depth, not surface field strength, is the parameter that decides whether weakly magnetic steel gets captured.
  • Electromagnetic overband separators allow current trimming; permanent magnets require height or circuit changes.
  • A 10-minute drop test and a spectrometer reading will settle the question on your site the same day.

Summary Table

Item

Description

Function

Explains why a self-cleaning magnet captures manganese steel liners and how to stop it without losing real tramp iron protection

Material in question

Hadfield manganese steel (ASTM A128 type, 11–14% Mn, austenitic when annealed)

Normal behavior

Weak paramagnetism only — should slide off a magnet plate under its own weight

When it becomes magnetic

Work hardening, welding, incomplete solution annealing, or substitution with carbon steel

Main risks

Magnet belt damage, chute jamming, false tramp iron counts, steel contamination in product

First check

Material verification: magnet drop test + spark/spectro test + mill certificate

Main fix

Replace magnetic steel upstream; raise suspension height; select shallower field or trim electromagnet current

Self-Cleaning Magnet Keeps Picking Up Manganese Steel — 1

Failure Analysis

Problem

Possible Cause

Recommended Solution

Full liners captured and carried on magnet belt

Carbon steel substitution or magnetic weld zones

Spectro test; replace magnetic steel; ban unverified repairs

Weak cling on genuine Hadfield coupon

Work-hardened surface + deep field

Raise suspension height in 50 mm steps; re-run capture test

Pickup began after magnet replacement

New circuit deeper than old unit

Compare field-depth ratings; trim current or change circuit

Magnet belt damaged by captured steel

Discharge chute cannot release large items

Redesign chute clearance; add crusher pre-break for large scrap

False tramp iron counts inflated

Weakly magnetic debris captured routinely

Sort captured steel by category; fix material side

Real knife-edge scrap missed after height increase

Over-correction of suspension height

Validate with knife-edge test piece; settle height between the two limits

Steel fragments in final product

Magnet weakened to avoid pickup; fragments bypassed

Restore field; solve material upstream; add secondary capture

Recurring pickup of repair pieces

Maintenance offcuts entering feed

Shutdown housekeeping procedure + magnet audit before restart

FAQ

Q1: Is it normal for a self-cleaning magnet to pick up manganese steel at all?

A: No — not firmly. Annealed Hadfield manganese steel is paramagnetic and should slide off under its own weight. Weak cling of heavily work-hardened surfaces is possible; snap-on capture means the piece is carbon steel, welded, poorly annealed, or the field is unusually deep. Treat firm pickup as a material or specification problem first.

Q2: How can I test whether my "manganese steel" liner is genuine on site?

A: Start with a magnet drop test: annealed Hadfield will not support its own weight on a magnet plate. Then use a spark test for a coarse alloy check and a portable spectrometer for confirmation against the certificate. Any piece that snaps onto a handheld magnet like a tool deserves a spectro test before you blame the separator.

Q3: My magnet captures liners only after we weld repairs on them. Why?

A: Weld metal and the heat-affected zone develop magnetic phases even when the parent plate stays austenitic. On Hadfield steel, repair welding without proper control and re-annealing makes the repaired zone ferromagnetic. Verify repaired liners with a magnet test before returning them to the line, and prefer replacement over patching on impact-loaded parts.Self-Cleaning Magnet Keeps Picking Up Manganese Steel — 2

Contact Us

Contact: Annie Lu

Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com

Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676

Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com

We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.

prev
Self-Cleaning Overband Magnet Installation Angle:
How Do I Size a Self-Cleaning Suspended Magnet for a 1,200 mm Conveyor at 800 t/h?
next
recommended for you
Get in touch with us
Customer service