Huatao Group-Vibrating Screen Technology Solution and Service for Quarry & Mining Industry Since 2008.
Genuine, correctly solution-annealed Hadfield manganese steel is essentially paramagnetic and should not cling firmly to a self-cleaning magnetic separator. If your magnet keeps lifting manganese steel liners, the usual causes are mislabeled carbon steel, magnetic weld zones, work-hardened surfaces that have developed strain-induced martensite, or a field that reaches too deep for the duty. In practice, material identity explains roughly 70% of these cases; field tuning explains most of the rest. Verify the steel first, then adjust suspension height or field depth — never simply accept the pickup as normal.
|
Item |
Description |
|
Function |
Explains why a self-cleaning magnet captures manganese steel liners and how to stop it without losing real tramp iron protection |
|
Material in question |
Hadfield manganese steel (ASTM A128 type, 11–14% Mn, austenitic when annealed) |
|
Normal behavior |
Weak paramagnetism only — should slide off a magnet plate under its own weight |
|
When it becomes magnetic |
Work hardening, welding, incomplete solution annealing, or substitution with carbon steel |
|
Main risks |
Magnet belt damage, chute jamming, false tramp iron counts, steel contamination in product |
|
First check |
Material verification: magnet drop test + spark/spectro test + mill certificate |
|
Main fix |
Replace magnetic steel upstream; raise suspension height; select shallower field or trim electromagnet current |
|
Problem |
Possible Cause |
Recommended Solution |
|
Full liners captured and carried on magnet belt |
Carbon steel substitution or magnetic weld zones |
Spectro test; replace magnetic steel; ban unverified repairs |
|
Weak cling on genuine Hadfield coupon |
Work-hardened surface + deep field |
Raise suspension height in 50 mm steps; re-run capture test |
|
Pickup began after magnet replacement |
New circuit deeper than old unit |
Compare field-depth ratings; trim current or change circuit |
|
Magnet belt damaged by captured steel |
Discharge chute cannot release large items |
Redesign chute clearance; add crusher pre-break for large scrap |
|
False tramp iron counts inflated |
Weakly magnetic debris captured routinely |
Sort captured steel by category; fix material side |
|
Real knife-edge scrap missed after height increase |
Over-correction of suspension height |
Validate with knife-edge test piece; settle height between the two limits |
|
Steel fragments in final product |
Magnet weakened to avoid pickup; fragments bypassed |
Restore field; solve material upstream; add secondary capture |
|
Recurring pickup of repair pieces |
Maintenance offcuts entering feed |
Shutdown housekeeping procedure + magnet audit before restart |
Q1: Is it normal for a self-cleaning magnet to pick up manganese steel at all?
A: No — not firmly. Annealed Hadfield manganese steel is paramagnetic and should slide off under its own weight. Weak cling of heavily work-hardened surfaces is possible; snap-on capture means the piece is carbon steel, welded, poorly annealed, or the field is unusually deep. Treat firm pickup as a material or specification problem first.
Q2: How can I test whether my "manganese steel" liner is genuine on site?
A: Start with a magnet drop test: annealed Hadfield will not support its own weight on a magnet plate. Then use a spark test for a coarse alloy check and a portable spectrometer for confirmation against the certificate. Any piece that snaps onto a handheld magnet like a tool deserves a spectro test before you blame the separator.
Q3: My magnet captures liners only after we weld repairs on them. Why?
A: Weld metal and the heat-affected zone develop magnetic phases even when the parent plate stays austenitic. On Hadfield steel, repair welding without proper control and re-annealing makes the repaired zone ferromagnetic. Verify repaired liners with a magnet test before returning them to the line, and prefer replacement over patching on impact-loaded parts.
Contact: Annie Lu
Email: annie.lu@huataogroup.com
Phone / WhatsApp: +86 180 3242 2676
Website: http://www.tufflexscreen.com
We warmly welcome customers from around the world to contact us and establish mutually beneficial partnerships.
Contact: Annie Lu
Tel: +86 18032422676
E-mail: manager11@huataogroup.com
Address: Zhonghua North Street, Shijiazhuang, Hebei, China